Baron Nashor
Card Text & Abilities
As you play me, add the Baron Pit battlefield token to the board if it's not there already. If you do, I enter there. I can't be chosen by enemy spells and abilities. Other friendly units have +2 [S].
Judge Rulings & Interactions
5 Judge RulingsMoving means changing position between spaces on the board, while entering the board from another zone is a zone change. When Baron Nashor creates the Baron Pit, his replacement effect changes his entry location from the originally chosen location to the Baron Pit.
The Baron Pit is created uncontrolled.
Baron Nashor enters it and contests it for his controller.
His entry causes a cleanup, which stages a showdown at the Baron Pit.
That showdown normally begins during the cleanup. If multiple showdowns are ready to begin, the turn player chooses which one begins.
The Baron Pit remains uncontrolled while the showdown is ongoing.
The showdown closes after every player passes focus in sequence without playing a card or activating an ability. If Baron Nashor's controller is then the only player with units there, they establish control of the Baron Pit and conquer it if they have not scored it that turn.
Suppose Baron Nashor is assigned lethal combat damage and a friendly Evelynn, Entrancing is assigned 2 combat damage.
Lethal-damage check: Baron Nashor has lethal damage, while Evelynn's 2 marked damage is less than her current 4 might: 2 printed might plus Baron Nashor's +2. Of the two, only Baron Nashor has lethal damage during the check, so the cleanup kills him and not Evelynn.
Baron Nashor's passive ability stops applying when he leaves the board. Evelynn therefore returns to 2 might after the lethal-damage check has finished. Her 2 marked damage is now lethal. That cleanup does not check her again.
Combat healing: The combat special cleanup heals all units, clearing Evelynn's marked damage.
Baron Nashor's departure causes another cleanup. Evelynn has no marked damage when that cleanup checks for lethal damage, so she is not killed.
If the Baron Pit is not on the board, Baron Nashor's "as you play me" instruction adds it and his replacement effect changes his entry from your chosen base to the Baron Pit.
If the Baron Pit is already on the board, Baron Nashor does not add it, so the conditional replacement does not apply and he enters your chosen base.
Official Rules FAQ & Clarifications
2 Official FAQsHunters’ Circle applies a cost reduction to the first unit or gear each player plays there during their turn. Baron Nashor entering at the Baron Pit is a replacement effect that applies while Baron resolves and enters the board. In comparison, Hunters’ Circle’s cost reduction is in effect during finalization, when choosing play locations in step 2 and determining the total cost in step 3. By the time Baron Nashor’s replacement effect applies, his cost has been determined and paid.
Relevant Rules: 355.2.
Riven, the Exile applies a replacement effect to units her controller plays to a battlefield they control. This refers to step 2 of finalization, when players pick the play location for a unit they are playing. Riven then generates a replacement effect for those units, which causes them to enter ready. When Baron Nashor enters in this scenario, there are two replacement effects that apply to the event of him entering: him entering ready, and him entering to the Baron Pit. Regardless of the order of these replacement effects, Baron Nashor will enter ready at the Baron Pit.
Relevant Rules: 355.2.