Gravity Field
Card Text & Abilities
[Deploy] (Play this only to a battlefield. When an opponent holds here, kill this.)
Opponents must pay [1][A] to move one or more units to this battlefield.
[Deathknell][>] Draw 1. (When I die, get the effect.)
Judge Rulings & Interactions
3 Judge RulingsRelevant rules: [CR 204.4.c].
The player who performs a game action is responsible for it. For example, Charm and Siren's Song each instruct you to move an enemy unit, so you are responsible even though your opponent controls that unit. Gravity Field's applied cost applies only when an opponent performs the move action to its battlefield.
For example, Angler Wyrm and Call to Battle each instruct a chosen opponent to perform the move, so that opponent is responsible for it. Gravity Field therefore applies its cost to that move action. Applied costs are paid as their associated game actions are performed.
The word "must" does not remove the option to decline an applied cost. If the opponent declines or cannot pay, they cannot perform the move action. The move instruction is negated rather than ignored because it cannot be followed for a reason other than an illegal target or unavailable information.
Official Rules FAQ & Clarifications
3 Official FAQsThe Standard Move is an inherent ability. We’ll clarify some established consensus on how the Standard Move operates: you cannot attempt to perform the Standard Move if the resulting move is not possible, nor if you cannot pay its associated costs.
Additionally, if the Standard Move incurs a Cost that cannot be paid, or if the move action cannot otherwise be performed, the Standard Move and all actions taken as part of performing it will be undone, any effects those actions caused to occur are similarly undone, and the Standard Move will be cancelled.
The opponent must pay [1][A] to move a unit to the battlefield with Gravity Field, but Charm instructs you to move the enemy unit and not your opponent.
If your opponent controlled the Gravity Field at that battlefield, you would be the one who would have to pay [1][A] to move the enemy unit to that battlefield when Charm resolves.
Relevant Rules: 412.2. and its subrules
Unlike Charm, Angler Wyrm instructs your opponent to move their unit, so they must pay the cost in order to move it to that battlefield. If they choose not to or can’t, the unit does not move.
Relevant Rules: 412.2. and its subrules, 204.4., 204.4.b., 204.4.c.