Nocturne, Horrifying
Banned in Constructed Format
Cost Reduction AbuseOfficial Ban Reason: Easily discounted down to 1 Power in early turns through trash filling, presenting overwhelming stats and board pressure far ahead of curve.
Card Text & Abilities
[Ganking] (I can move from battlefield to battlefield.) When you look at cards from the top of your deck (and don't draw them) and see me, you may play me for [A].
Official Errata
Official Rules ChangeWhen you look at cards from the top of your deck (and don't draw them) and see me, you may play me for [Universal].
As you look at or reveal me from the top of your deck, you may banish me. If you do, you may play me for [Universal].
Judge Rulings & Interactions
1 Judge RulingRules citation needed
Core Rules 1.5 explains how Nocturne's replacement effect applies when a qualifying look or reveal occurs, but "look" still has no standalone numbered action definition. Unlike reveal, the rules do not expressly state that a player looks at cards only when instructed. This ruling relies on treating "look at" as an instructed event; an official definition is still needed.
Nocturne's replacement-effect condition, "As you look at or reveal me from the top of your deck," does not itself instruct you to look at or reveal it. It can apply only while a qualifying look or reveal event is being processed.
In either case, Nocturne becomes public when it reaches the trash. Under the same interpretation, becoming public does not mean you looked at it from the top of your deck. It also does not mean you revealed it from there because revealing a card is a specific game action performed when instructed.