Orianna, Lady of Clockwork
Card Text & Abilities
At the start of your Main Phase, you may pay [1] to choose a friendly gear. It becomes a unit gear with Might equal to its Energy cost until you choose another gear with me.
Judge Rulings & Interactions
12 Judge RulingsThe Unit still has the [Equip] ability, and you can activate it, but on resolution the Unit will not be Attached to another Unit. The action would be negated ([CR 435.1.h.1]).
Relevant rules: [CR 435.1.h.1].
Because [Deploy] only limits the location it is played to and not the following positioning ([CR 830.1.b]).
Relevant rules: [CR 830.1.b].
Relevant rules: [CR 119.1], [CR 124], [CR 415.2], [CR 416.2].
It starts a non-Combat Showdown because one of your Units becomes present at a Battlefield you don’t control. If there was an enemy Unit there, a Combat Showdown would start because your Unit becomes present at a Battlefield your opponent controls. ([CR 190.3.a]; [CR 323.7]; [CR 323.8]).
Relevant rules: [CR 190.3.a], [CR 323.7], [CR 323.8].
Relevant rules: [CR 323.6].
This happens because it is considered a Unit Gear only while it remains on the board and is affected by Orianna, Lady of Clockwork’s ability. When banished, it will return a Gear.
Relevant rules: [CR 124].
2) No.
Gear (A) will not be considered Attached to the newly “animated" Gear (C), therefore will not give its benefits to Gear (C).
3) No.
As stated above, Gear (A) is not considered Attached to the newly “animated" Gear (C), so (C) will receive the Might Bonus and the appended effect text only from Gear (B).
4) No.
Because Gear (A) is Attached to (B) and not to the newly “animated" Gear (C). If (C) dies, Gear (B) will be detached and it will still have Gear (A) Attached to it.
Relevant rules: [CR 717], [CR 435.1.c].
While Lady of Clockwork's effect applies, the gear's current unit type satisfies the unit requirement for each effect's choice. Lady of Clockwork changes the gear's actual type and might without changing its copyable traits. Copy effects use the gear's printed traits, the traits it had when created as a token, or traits supplied by an existing copy effect, so they do not include Lady of Clockwork's changes.
Lady of Clockwork's gear choice is made during finalization. Lady of Clockwork's stated duration therefore ends when the new gear is chosen, not when the ability resolves. Finalizing the ability makes a cleanup outstanding. That cleanup must finish before play proceeds. The new ability cannot resolve during it. Priority is not passed or awarded during it. During that cleanup, an unattached non-unit gear at a battlefield is recalled unless it has Deploy.
Example
Lady of Clockwork makes Helm of Suppression a unit gear, then Svellsongur attaches to it. Svellsongur copies Helm of Suppression's printed rules text into its effect text for as long as it remains attached. When Lady of Clockwork chooses another gear, Helm of Suppression stops being a unit but Svellsongur remains attached. The copied effect text remains appended to Helm of Suppression's rules text, so Helm of Suppression is a non-unit gear with two instances of its printed rules text.
Official Rules FAQ & Clarifications
3 Official FAQsIn this rules update we’ve clarified that units cannot be attached to other game objects. If a unit were to be attached to a game object, it would need to stop being a unit first. If a non-unit game object becomes a unit, it will detach from anything it is attached to as it becomes a unit. If an effect would attempt to attach a unit to another game object without making it no longer a unit first, nothing happens.
Relevant rules: [CR 143.5], [CR 435.1.h], [CR 718.6].
Relevant rules: [CR 190.3.a], [CR 323.7], [CR 323.8], [CR 323.11], [CR 323.12].
Although units cannot be attached to objects, other objects have no such compunctions. Any attached Equipment that don’t become units will remain attached to the gear even after it stops being a unit. Their Might bonus won’t apply, since the gear doesn’t have a Might, but they will continue to apply their effect text to the gear they are attached to.
The majority of gear with Deploy reference “this battlefield” or “hold here” in such a way that gaining a benefit from base is not possible. That being said, if you want to move it back to a battlefield you can either turn it into a unit again with Orianna, Lady of Clockwork or you can use movement effects that specify moving gear, such as Command: Attack.
Note that there is a small gap between finalizing the Orianna, Lady of Clockwork trigger causing the previous unit-gear to stop being a unit, and the triggered ability resolving and causing the new gear to become a unit. During that gap, neither gear is a unit unless it was already one prior to ever being chosen by Orianna, Lady of Clockwork.
Relevant rules: [CR 137.3.b].