Rebuttal
Card Text & Abilities
[Reaction] (Play any time, even before spells and abilities resolve.) Choose a spell with Energy cost no more than [4]. You may pay [A]. If you do, gain control of it and you may make new choices for it. Otherwise, counter it.
Judge Rulings & Interactions
4 Judge RulingsRebuttal allows you to remake a finalized spell's targets, but every new target must still be legal. When a spell is played from face down, its targets must be chosen from among the options at the battlefield where it was hidden unless the spell's own targeting restriction makes that impossible. Changing the spell's controller does not change where it was played from, so this restriction continues to apply.
Example
An opponent plays Hidden Blade from face down and chooses a unit at that battlefield. If you gain control of Hidden Blade with Rebuttal, you may choose another legal unit at the same battlefield. You cannot choose a unit at another battlefield, and you cannot choose a unit at base because Hidden Blade itself requires a unit "at a battlefield."
Rules citation needed
Core Rules 1.5 says an ability that triggers when "you" do something checks for a game action for which that player is responsible. It does not say that gaining control of a finalized spell transfers responsibility for the spell's earlier play game action. The new-controller outcome above therefore still relies on the official FAQ ruling.
Example
Suppose you and your opponent each control Ravenbloom Student, and you use Rebuttal to gain control of your opponent's Gust. Your Ravenbloom Student triggers when Rebuttal resolves under your control. If Gust then resolves under your control, your Ravenbloom Student triggers again, while your opponent's Ravenbloom Student does not trigger for Gust.
Official Rules FAQ & Clarifications
4 Official FAQsIf you are remaking choices in this way, any choices you choose not to remake must be legal choices. You can’t choose to have some but not all choices be legal choices. Of course, you can always choose not to make new choices. In that case, any of the current choices will remain in their current state, whether that state is illegal or not.
If a spell has some rules or requirements about the choices made for it, those apply regardless of who controls that spell. For example, if a player plays a spell from face down, they must target game objects located at the battlefield the spell was played from unless the instructions of that spell indicate that a target must be chosen from some other location. Gaining control of such a spell doesn’t change this requirement when making new choices for the spell.
We’ll look at shaping up this section in a future rules update.
Ravenbloom Student’s triggered ability checks whether a spell that you control resolves. You gained control of the Stupefy, and it resolved, so you will have triggered Ravenbloom Student’s ability. Battering Ram and Legion, on the other hand, check whether cards were finalized . Although you gained control of Stupefy, you did not finalize it; you got it after it was already finalized by your opponent. Thus, your opponent’s Legion abilities will be active, and Battering Ram will only receive a [1] Energy discount.
Relevant Rules: 419.4., 419.4.a., 419.4.b.
Similar to the previous model, all decisions must be legal and valid; however, with this new model, any abilities that trigger on targeting, for example, will trigger again; even if you previously targeted the same unit. It should feel like you’re going through the process of choosing targets all over again.