Mordekaiser, Twice Slain
Card Text & Abilities
[Accelerate] (You may pay [1][C] as an additional cost to have me enter ready.)
[Assault 3] (+3 [S] while I'm an attacker.)
Once each turn, if I would die, you may kill a friendly unit to heal me, exhaust me, and recall me instead.
Judge Rulings & Interactions
6 Judge RulingsAfter lethal damage is assigned, Mordekaiser, Twice Slainβs ability allows you to kill one other Unit to heal, exhaust and recall him to Base instead of dying. Since Replacement Effects take place before any qualifying event has actually occurred ([CR 370.1.c]), the Unit that should die along Mordekaiser, Twice Slain has not died yet, so it is possible to kill it to apply the Replacement Effect.
Relevant rules: [CR 369], [CR 369.1], [CR 370.1.c].
If Mordekaiser, Twice Slain uses his ability to prevent his death, Baited Hookβs kill instruction is replaced and does not occur. Because there is no βkilled Unit" to reference for the Might (actually, the value used is NULL), you cannot play a Unit from Baited Hookβs effect (the instruction is ignored). However, looking at the top 5 cards of your main deck is not dependent on the Unit being killed, so you still perform that action. Since you cannot play any Unit among them, all 5 cards are considered βthe rest" and must be recycled.
Relevant rules: [CR 370.1.a.1], [CR 359.3.e.6], [CR 359.3.e.14], [CR 359.3.e.14.b].
Combat damage itself does not kill either unit. The kill action happens during the combat cleanup that follows, which would kill all units with lethal damage simultaneously. Here, "simultaneously" describes the kills that cleanup is about to perform; it does not mean those units are already dead.
Replacement effects apply before the events they replace, so his effect steps in before the cleanup kills happen. At that point, the other friendly unit is still on the board. It may have lethal damage and be about to die, but you can still kill it to pay the cost of saving him. Paying that cost performs a separate kill action before cleanup performs any simultaneous kills left unchanged. His own death is replaced, so he is healed, exhausted, and recalled instead.
The same timing applies to spells outside combat:
If Mordekaiser's card would go to your trash, both effects initially apply to his death, so you choose their order as his controller. If Mordekaiser's effect applies first and you choose another friendly unit, killing that unit is the cost of saving him. If that unit's card would go to your trash, Endless Riches replaces killing it with banishing its card instead. Replacing its associated game action does not undo the payment. If Endless Riches does not apply to the chosen unit, that unit is killed normally to pay the cost. Mordekaiser's effect therefore heals, exhausts, and recalls him.
If Endless Riches applies to Mordekaiser's original death and you apply it first, it banishes him instead of killing him, leaving no death for his replacement effect to replace.
Replacing Mordekaiser's original death means the kill action from the opponent's spell does not occur. Mordekaiser's replacement effect cannot apply again to the kill used to pay that cost. You perform that new kill action as the cost, so you are responsible for it. Because Mordekaiser's ability contains the kill instruction, the kill is attributed to that ability and to Mordekaiser, not to the opponent's spell. An Immortal Phoenix in that opponent's trash triggers only if they are responsible for a kill attributed to a spell they control.
Replacing Mordekaiser's death means Deathgrip's kill action does not occur. The conditional might instruction directly references that kill and therefore does not execute, while the draw instruction does not reference it and still executes. Killing a unit to pay Mordekaiser's replacement cost is a separate kill action attributed to his ability, not the Deathgrip action that was replaced.