Temporal Breach
Card Text & Abilities
[Hidden] (Hide now for [A] to react with later for [0].) Banish a unit, then its owner plays it to the same location, ignoring its cost.
Judge Rulings & Interactions
11 Judge RulingsIf you play Temporal Breach normally, the Hidden restriction does not apply. You may target an otherwise legal unit at any battlefield or base.
Detached equipment at a battlefield is recalled to its controller's base during the next cleanup. Detached equipment at a base its controller does not control is recalled to its controller's base during cleanup. Equipment already at its controller's base remains there.
Example
Ahri, Inquisitive's "When I attack or defend" ability triggers when she first gains the defender designation. If Temporal Breach then banishes her and her owner plays her again at that battlefield, the new Ahri object gains the designation during cleanup and can trigger the ability again.
The unit becomes a new game object, but Ravenbloom Conservatory does not. As the defending player, you keep the defender designation until combat ends, so the unit's return does not cause you to gain it again.
Example
If Temporal Breach banishes Cruel Patron and its owner has no other friendly unit, they can't pay Cruel Patron's mandatory additional cost to kill a friendly unit. Cruel Patron cannot finish finalizing and returns to its owner's banishment.
Banishment leaves you with no units at the battlefield and incurs a cleanup, but that cleanup waits for Temporal Breach to finish resolving.
The unit's owner begins playing it by moving it to the chain, where it remains pending while Temporal Breach finishes resolving.
The pending unit remains on the chain throughout the cleanup, so you retain control.
The unit then finalizes and enters the same battlefield under its owner's control.
With Rockfall Path, the owner begins playing the unit, moving it from banishment to the chain as a pending card. Its finalization waits until Temporal Breach finishes resolving. Temporal Breach requires the unit to be played to its previous location, but Rockfall Path forbids units from being played there, so the unit fails its legality check. That play is cancelled and undone, returning the unit to its owner's banishment.
With Brynhir Thundersong, the owner cannot begin the play game action, so the unit never leaves banishment. The impossible play instruction is negated, and Temporal Breach continues resolving after doing as much as possible.
Official Rules FAQ & Clarifications
2 Official FAQsIn general, there are not many cases where we have this kind of competing instruction: one effect that tells you to play a unit to one location, and one that tells you to play it to another. That being said, when they do arise with contradictory requirements, the precedent from other areas of the rules is that the player chooses one of those requirements and ignores all others.
Note that this only applies to mandatory positive requirements, ones that specify a location or method without also preventing the action from being performed to other locations or with other methods and that aren’t optional. For example, an effect like Perched Grimwyrm’s passive ability is a restriction on playing that unit to any location other than a battlefield you’ve conquered this turn. Rockfall Path’s passive ability is a restriction on playing units to Rockfall Path. If you’ve conquered only Rockfall Path this turn, you can’t play Perched Grimwyrm at all, because those two restrictions are contradictory.
In this case, the contradictory requirements don’t directly prohibit the playing of these units to other locations, so we can choose one of the contradictory requirements and ignore the rest.
Units cannot be played to a base of a player other than their own controller under any circumstances. Because the owner of the unit is the one being instructed to play the unit, and the location they are being instructed to play it to is a base other than their own, it isn’t possible to play the unit. During the check legality step of finalization, the unit will be returned to banishment from the chain and all actions taken will be undone.